The scoring began in the first inning when Atlantis University took the lead. Fernando Fernandez induced Alex Socarras into a fielder's choice, allowing one run to score. However, the Bobcats quickly responded, tying the game at one in the bottom of the first on a wild pitch. In the fourth inning, St. Thomas University gained the lead with a solo home run from Frank Diaz, pushing the score to 2-1. The game remained competitive, with Justin Suarez hitting a single in the top of the sixth to equalize at two runs. After the sixth inning, the Bobcats pulled ahead again. Axel Olvera contributed to the score with a single in the bottom of the sixth, making it 3-2. The Bobcats strengthened their lead with three runs in the seventh inning, highlighted by a home run from Hill.

Despite trailing, Atlantis University fought back at the top of the eighth, tying the game again. This comeback was achieved through a combination of a ground out by Suarez, a walk by Eddy Perez, a single from Jony Vasallo, and another walk from Walter Mammarella. In the bottom of the eighth, St. Thomas University regained the lead after Matthew Zamora's double to left field and an error by Atlantis University, each scoring one run. Frank Vila won the Bobcats victory, pitching one inning without allowing any runs. Alejandro Uribe was credited with the loss for Atlantis University after one inning of work, where he allowed two runs (one earned) on just one hit.

Josh Polanco started for Atlantis University, giving up four hits, two runs over four innings, and two strikeouts. Conversely, for the Bobcats, Fernandez surrendered only one run in his inning of work with no hits against him. Justin Negron later secured the save for the Bobcats. Atlantis University showcased a notable offensive performance, amassing 12 hits overall. Suarez led with two runs batted in and a tally of 2-for-5 at the plate, while Perez also made significant contributions with two hits in five at-bats. The team displayed patience at the plate, accumulating eight walks during the game and executing one double play.

St. Thomas University had a balanced hitting effort with 11 total hits. Michael Malagon, Hill, Olvera, and Ruben Gandarila each contributed two hits. Hill stood out with three runs batted in, going 2-for-4 at the plate. Additionally, the Bobcats were effective defensively, turning two double plays throughout the game.