The season began with a challenging matchup against Webber University, which resulted in a 67-0 defeat. This outcome left more questions than answers about how the season would progress and the coaches' ability to adapt for future games. The second game, against Warner University, was more competitive. Warner established their game early, but Atlantis forced them into passing situations, capitalizing on their weaknesses while showcasing strong defensive resistance. Offensive strategies improved with Bennett Riffer as the new quarterback, who scored his first touchdown. Wide receiver Tony Morgan set a school record with a remarkable 76-yard touchdown reception in this game.

Atlantis claimed a narrow 7-6 victory in a contested match against West Bay University. West Bay started strong, scoring 6 points in the first quarter but missing a crucial field goal. Atlantis turned the game around with a decisive rush, as Bennett Riffer scored his second touchdown, followed by a successful extra point from Jacob McCarter. The game ended early due to weather conditions.

 AU then faced a brutal defeat at Auto Nation Field, losing 56-0 to St. Thomas University (STU). Despite the scoreline, AU players showed resilience throughout the game. However, poor decision-making and teamwork failures hindered their performance against the skilled STU team. This game served as a learning opportunity, highlighting areas for improvement in future matchups.

A 48-8 victory over Advance Prep Academy (APA) at Carter Park in Fort Lauderdale, FL, was a motivating boost for AU. Quarterback Bennett Riffer set a school record with his fourth touchdown of the season while running back Camron Thompson scored two touchdowns. Wide receivers Jason Dummont and Tony Morgan each contributed a touchdown, and linebacker Tristan Ramsey added a defensive touchdown. Free safety Coreyon Harris, named MVP, recorded two safeties and scored a defensive touchdown. Kicker Jacob McCarter made three field goals, solidifying AU's second-season victory.