Initially, the Atlanteans struggled against RPA's potent aerial offense, trailing 7-14 at halftime. Quarterback Junly Deller's return and Coach Joel Williams's inspiring halftime speech spurred the team's resurgence. The defense, led by Tristan Ramsey and Malkaih Robinson, played a crucial role in the game's final moments, securing a remarkable comeback victory.

The following week, AU traveled to Jacksonville to face the Mocs in a thrilling game ending with a tight 24-21 win—the team's only road victory.

AU then delivered a decisive 25-2 victory over Southwest Community Christian College (SW CCC) at Ives Estate Park. Despite several attempts, AU's offense initially struggled, allowing SW CCC to take a 2-0 lead in the first quarter. Defensive lineman Kennard Thomas turned the tide with a touchdown, giving AU a 6-2 lead at halftime. Camron Thompson extended AU's lead in the final quarter with a touchdown. A pivotal interception by Jaden Henry halted SW CCC's comeback efforts, while tight end Kenwuan Harris and running back Anthony Bridgewater each added a touchdown, finalizing a dominant 25-2 victory.